| Rk | Player | School | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Blaine Gabbert | Missouri | 92 |
| 2. | Ryan Mallett | Arkansas | 87 |
| 3. | Andy Dalton | TCU | 80 |
| 4. | Christian Ponder | Florida State | 78 |
| 5. | Jake Locker | Washington | 74 |
| 6. | Cam Newton | Auburn | 69 |
| 7. | Ricky Stanzi | Iowa | 68 |
| 8. | Pat Devlin | Delaware | 62 |
| 9. | Colin Kaepernick | Penn State | 61 |
| 10. | Greg McElroy | Alabama | 60 |
| 11. | T.J. Yates | North Carolina | 53 |
| 12. | Tyrod Taylor | Virginia Tech | 50 |
| 13. | Adam Weber | Minnesota | 45 |
| 14. | Nathan Enderle | Idaho | 45 |
| 15. | Ben Chapell | Indiana | 45 |
| 16. | Jeff Van Camp | Florida Atlantic | 45 |
| 17. | Josh Portis | California (PA) | 45 |
| 18. | Mitch Mustain | USC | 45 |
| 19. | Scott Tolzien | Wisconsin | 35 |
| 20. | Jerrod Johnson | Texas A&M | 35 |
| 21. | Justin Roper | Montana | 35 |
| 22. | Arvell Nelson | Texas Southern | 35 |
| 23. | Taylor Potts | Texas Tech | 35 |
| 24. | Blake Bolles | N.W. Missouri State | 35 |
| 25. | Mike Hartline | Kentucky | 35 |
| 26. | Ryan Colburn | Fresno State | 35 |
